Is Airbnb creating a housing bubble that needs bursting?

Walk through central Christchurch on a weekday and you could be forgiven for thinking the city had been evacuated again.
That is the picture painted by Frank Film’s documentary Are we building a ghost town in Christchurch? Rank upon rank of new apartments. Empty courtyards. Wheelie bins left on the kerb all week because nobody lives there to bring them in.
The 2012 recovery blueprint promised 20,000 inner-city residents and “the most liveable city in New Zealand“. The same year, Airbnb arrived. City councillor Nathaniel Herz Jardine says the central city gained 484 new dwellings but only 50 new residents in a year.
The 2023 Census found 1,050 of the 5,274 private dwellings inside the Four Avenues unoccupied — 19.9 per cent, more than double Christchurch’s citywide rate of 8.1 per cent. Thousands more units have been built since.
A midweek Airbnb search for nights this December returns 267 listings in the central-city core alone. One resident in the film checks regularly. On the night of filming, 400 sat empty.
Another owner-occupier, who bought in a decade ago expecting neighbours to follow, counts 25 units in the block: three owner-occupied, perhaps two long-term rentals. “But for the most part, they’re Airbnbs.”
The business model is no secret. Market analyst Mike Blackburn says the units are being “built and being marketed and sold as Airbnb units“. Surge pricing on concert and Crusaders nights is so extreme, Herz Jardine explains, that owners “can just leave it empty the rest of the time“.
That model needs a steady drip of spectacle. Ratepayers and taxpayers have obliged: a $683 million stadium, $230 million of it from the Crown, plus a council events fund to lure the stars. Meanwhile short-stay owners pay residential rates, “dodging about half of their city taxes“, Herz Jardine says.
Even the market is choking on it. Average short-stay income in Christchurch fell to $105 a night — the first drop in five years — as hosts flooded the market ahead of the stadium.
Christchurch’s blank canvas made a few developers very rich, very quickly. Some now bankroll the party writing housing policy.
That should trouble Minister for the South Island James Meager. His remedy for Queenstown is to build more houses until Airbnb returns fall so far that owners sell or rent long-term. Christchurch has run that experiment. Returns fell. The units stayed empty.
Queenstown is further down the same road. On census night, 177 of Queenstown Central’s 393 dwellings — 45 per cent — were unoccupied. Across the district it was 27.4 per cent.
Now the template is spreading to Five Mile and Frankton. A Five Mile Villas townhouse is advertised as a “turnkey Airbnb investment“. Mountain Oak apartments at Remarkables Park come with 365-day visitor accommodation consent. Even Jacks Point and Hanley’s Farm carry dozens of listings.
Locals are pushed further out along Ladies Mile, where a ten-minute drive now takes ninety and the wastewater plant is overflowing. The boom needs builders, who need housing, who need more builders. As I have written before, it is a self-feeding monster.
Jackson Hole, Wyoming, shows where it ends: median house prices 14 times median incomes, and the people who run the town sleeping in their cars.
Airbnb points to research it commissioned finding short-term rentals barely move rents. That misses the point. Most of these units were never rentals. They are hotel rooms in residential clothing, financed by a property-industrial complex that sets the rules.
The fixes are not radical. A national register forcing platforms to disclose addresses. Commercial rates for commercial use. Zoning powers to declare residents-only neighbourhoods, as Barcelona is doing by 2028. MBIE has already backed a ruling that Christchurch Airbnb owners need consent or must stop. Enforce it.
What we don’t need is a bed tax that bills the tourist for a problem speculators built.
Christchurch was promised the most liveable city in New Zealand. Nobody asked who would be doing the living.



